[Openid-specs-ab] Roland Hedberg's federation specification

Nick Roy nroy at internet2.edu
Tue Jul 12 18:44:31 UTC 2016

There's also the REFEDS oidcre list, where Roland has solicited some good feedback from the multilateral R&E federation community.  I don't think having the OIDF adopt this and work on it is incompatible with discussion in the context of multilateral federations.  I'd be happy to encourage folks from the R&E space to, for example, join this list if it would help.  Agreeing to the IPR is difficult for some people representing higher ed institutions, but I know a couple of us have signed up as 'independent' successfully.

Let me know if there are things I can do to help facilitate this interaction.  I think Roland's work is very important, and I want to make sure it succeeds and that it can support the needs of multilateral federations.



On 7/11/16, 5:05 PM, "Openid-specs-ab on behalf of Mike Schwartz" <openid-specs-ab-bounces at lists.openid.net on behalf of mike at gluu.org> wrote:

OpenID WG,

I was reading the meeting notes today, and I want to interject my 
comments about Roland's OpenID Connect federation proposal.

First of all, my assessment of Roland's draft is that it has significant 
gaps, and it needs a lot of work.

I'm concerned that the imperatives of the main OpenID Connect group are 
consumer and enterprise authentication. Because this multi-party 
federration draft needs so much work, I think it would be better to 
develop it seperately, and bring it back to the main group when there is 
consensus on a solution.

There are a lot of interested parties with regard to the development of 
multi-party federation trust models who could contribute more 
effectively if the standard was developed under a more targeted working 
group. For example, as the co-chair of the Kantara OTTO WG, which was 
formed expressly to address the challenge of federation of Oauth2 
entities, I know we have a core group of people who are interested to 

It would be nice if whatever process takes place at OIDF should be an 
open, democratic forum, as several of us from OTTO would like to 

- Mike

Michael Schwartz
Founder / CEO
mike at gluu.org

Openid-specs-ab mailing list
Openid-specs-ab at lists.openid.net

More information about the Openid-specs-ab mailing list