[Openid-specs-ab] Issue #40: OP-D-02(Reject requests without nonce unless using the code flow) Shows wrong result (openid/certification)

Thu Jan 29 00:43:07 UTC 2015

New issue 40: OP-D-02(Reject requests without nonce unless using the code flow) Shows wrong result
https://bitbucket.org/openid/certification/issue/40/op-d-02-reject-requests-without-nonce

Edmund Jay:

In implicit flow, the OP returns an error. This behavior should pass the test but the result is displayed as failed (red light).

Below is the trace :

```
#!text

test info for OP-D-02

Test output

__RegistrationRequest:post__
[check]
	status: INFORMATION
	description: Registration Response
	info: {"client_id":"UXOOqJ_nZBk5FaACJOXUVg","client_secret":"EIQte0yFiVMYEg","registration_access_token":"bwVw3OtFPU_Eng","registration_client_uri":"https:\/\/connect.openid4.us\/abop\/op.php\/client\/HI0SM8M78ykAZ984UoXhBw","client_id_issued_at":1422491913,"client_secret_expires_at":0,"registration_client_uri_path":"HI0SM8M78ykAZ984UoXhBw","application_type":"web","redirect_uris":["https:\/\/oictest.umdc.umu.se:8102\/authz_cb"],"jwks_uri":"https:\/\/oictest.umdc.umu.se:8102\/export\/jwk_8102.json","subject_type":"public","id_token_signed_response_alg":"RS256","default_max_age":3600,"require_auth_time":true,"response_types":["id_token"],"grant_types":["implicit"]}
__AuthorizationRequest:pre__
[check-response-type]
	status: OK
	description: Checks that the asked for response type are among the supported
[check-endpoint]
	status: OK
	description: Checks that the necessary endpoint exists at a server
Trace output

0.000158 ------------ DiscoveryRequest ------------
0.000172 Provider info discover from 'https://connect.openid4.us/'
0.808434 ProviderConfigurationResponse: {'claims_supported': [u'name', u'given_name', u'family_name', u'middle_name', u'nickname', u'preferred_username', u'profile', u'picture', u'website', u'email', u'email_verified', u'gender', u'birthdate', u'zoneinfo', u'locale', u'phone_number', u'phone_number_verified', u'address', u'updated_at'], 'version': u'3.0', 'op_policy_uri': u'https://connect.openid4.us/abop/op.php/op_policy', 'subject_types_supported': [u'public', u'pairwise'], 'request_parameter_supported': True, 'userinfo_signing_alg_values_supported': [u'none', u'HS256', u'HS384', u'HS512', u'RS256', u'RS384', u'RS512'], 'issuer': u'https://connect.openid4.us', 'ui_locales_supported': [u'en-US'], 'id_token_encryption_enc_values_supported': [u'A128CBC-HS256', u'A256CBC-HS512', u'A128GCM', u'A256GCM'], 'require_request_uri_registration': False, 'grant_types_supported': [u'authorization_code', u'implicit'], 'token_endpoint': u'https://connect.openid4.us/abop/op.php/token', 'dis
 play_values_supported': [u'page'], 'request_uri_parameter_supported': True, 'claims_locales_supported': [u'en-US'], 'service_documentation': u'https://connect.openid4.us/abop/op.php/servicedocs', 'registration_endpoint': u'https://connect.openid4.us/abop/op.php/registration', 'jwks_uri': u'https://connect.openid4.us/connect4us.jwk', 'userinfo_encryption_alg_values_supported': [u'RSA1_5', u'RSA-OAEP'], 'scopes_supported': [u'openid', u'profile', u'email', u'address', u'phone', u'offline_access'], 'token_endpoint_auth_methods_supported': [u'client_secret_post', u'client_secret_basic', u'client_secret_jwt', u'private_key_jwt'], 'userinfo_encryption_enc_values_supported': [u'A128CBC-HS256', u'A256CBC-HS512', u'A128GCM', u'A256GCM'], 'id_token_signing_alg_values_supported': [u'none', u'HS256', u'HS384', u'HS512', u'RS256', u'RS384', u'RS512'], 'request_object_encryption_enc_values_supported': [u'A128CBC-HS256', u'A256CBC-HS512', u'A128GCM', u'A256GCM'], 'claims_parameter_supporte
 d': True, 'id_token_encryption_alg_values_supported': [u'RSA1_5', u'RSA-OAEP'], 'token_endpoint_auth_signing_alg_values_supported': [u'none', u'HS256', u'HS384', u'HS512', u'RS256', u'RS384', u'RS512'], 'userinfo_endpoint': u'https://connect.openid4.us/abop/op.php/userinfo', 'request_object_signing_alg_values_supported': [u'none', u'HS256', u'HS384', u'HS512', u'RS256', u'RS384', u'RS512'], 'op_tos_uri': u'https://connect.openid4.us/abop/op.php/op_tos', u'check_session_iframe': u'https://connect.openid4.us/abop/opframe.php/1', 'request_object_encryption_alg_values_supported': [u'RSA1_5', u'RSA-OAEP'], 'response_types_supported': [u'code', u'code token', u'code id_token', u'token', u'token id_token', u'code token id_token', u'id_token'], u'end_session_endpoint': u'https://connect.openid4.us/abop/op.php/endsession', 'authorization_endpoint': u'https://connect.openid4.us/abop/op.php/auth', 'claim_types_supported': [u'normal']}
1.550914 JWKS: {
 "keys":[
  {
   "kty":"RSA",
   "n":"tf_sB4M0sHearRLzz1q1JRgRdRnwk0lz-IcVDFlpp2dtDVyA-ZM8Tu1swp7upaTNykf7cp3Ne_6uW3JiKvRMDdNdvHWCzDHmbmZWGdnFF9Ve-D1cUxj4ETVpUM7AIXWbGs34fUNYl3Xzc4baSyvYbc3h6iz8AIdb_1bQLxJsHBi-ydg3NMJItgQJqBiwCmQYCOnJlekR-Ga2a5XlIx46Wsj3Pz0t0dzM8gVSU9fU3QrKKzDFCoFHTgig1YZNNW5W2H6QwANL5h-nbgre5sWmDmdnfiU6Pj5GOQDmp__rweinph8OAFNF6jVqrRZ3QJEmMnO42naWOsxV2FAUXafksQ",
   "e":"AQAB",
   "kid":"ABOP-00"
  }
 ]
}

1.551817 ------------ RegistrationRequest ------------
1.552158 --> URL: https://connect.openid4.us/abop/op.php/registration
1.552164 --> BODY: {"subject_type": "public", "jwks_uri": "https://oictest.umdc.umu.se:8102/export/jwk_8102.json", "application_type": "web", "grant_types": ["implicit"], "id_token_signed_response_alg": "RS256", "redirect_uris": ["https://oictest.umdc.umu.se:8102/authz_cb"], "response_types": ["id_token"], "require_auth_time": true, "scope": ["openid", "profile", "email", "address", "phone"], "default_max_age": 3600}
1.552170 --> HEADERS: {'Content-type': 'application/json'}
2.376896 <-- STATUS: 200
2.376969 <-- BODY: {"client_id":"UXOOqJ_nZBk5FaACJOXUVg","client_secret":"EIQte0yFiVMYEg","registration_access_token":"bwVw3OtFPU_Eng","registration_client_uri":"https:\/\/connect.openid4.us\/abop\/op.php\/client\/HI0SM8M78ykAZ984UoXhBw","client_id_issued_at":1422491913,"client_secret_expires_at":0,"registration_client_uri_path":"HI0SM8M78ykAZ984UoXhBw","application_type":"web","redirect_uris":["https:\/\/oictest.umdc.umu.se:8102\/authz_cb"],"jwks_uri":"https:\/\/oictest.umdc.umu.se:8102\/export\/jwk_8102.json","subject_type":"public","id_token_signed_response_alg":"RS256","default_max_age":3600,"require_auth_time":true,"response_types":["id_token"],"grant_types":["implicit"]}
2.377517 RegistrationResponse: {'client_id_issued_at': 1422491913, 'redirect_uris': [u'https://oictest.umdc.umu.se:8102/authz_cb'], 'jwks_uri': u'https://oictest.umdc.umu.se:8102/export/jwk_8102.json', 'application_type': u'web', 'registration_client_uri': u'https://connect.openid4.us/abop/op.php/client/HI0SM8M78ykAZ984UoXhBw', 'subject_type': u'public', 'id_token_signed_response_alg': u'RS256', u'registration_client_uri_path': u'HI0SM8M78ykAZ984UoXhBw', 'registration_access_token': u'bwVw3OtFPU_Eng', 'response_types': [u'id_token'], 'client_id': u'UXOOqJ_nZBk5FaACJOXUVg', 'require_auth_time': True, 'grant_types': [u'implicit'], 'client_secret': u'EIQte0yFiVMYEg', 'default_max_age': 3600, 'client_secret_expires_at': 0}
2.378676 ------------ AuthorizationRequest ------------
2.378953 --> URL: https://connect.openid4.us/abop/op.php/auth?scope=openid&state=YrnqVfZAAAunTvVO&redirect_uri=https%3A%2F%2Foictest.umdc.umu.se%3A8102%2Fauthz_cb&response_type=id_token&client_id=UXOOqJ_nZBk5FaACJOXUVg
2.378959 --> BODY: None
4.315597 <-- x
4.316016 [ERROR] ResponseError:Missing or faulty response
```