[OpenID] Summarizing my grouse with XRD

SitG Admin sysadmin at shadowsinthegarden.com
Wed Oct 21 23:12:47 UTC 2009


>Not necessarily all applications are security sensitive. Think about
>robots.txt. Does it have a Subject? No. Does it introduce security
>vulnerabilities? No. Is it metadata about something? Yes.

It can also be data about something.
(See the blog at 'webmasterworld.com' . . . '/robot.txt'!)
It can also contain active code (both IE and Firefox will process 
/robot.txt as HTML if the proper META tags are in that document, 
though Safari will not - I tested this several months ago when 
preparing a robot.txt file that would parse properly to webspiders 
(following the robots spec) *and* to more capable browsers as full 
HTML), which introduces a security vulnerability for browsers that 
only place security restrictions (for active scripting) on filetypes 
(identified by extension) that *should* contain scripts. The upcoming 
(draft) spec for HTML 5 has a section addressing this, but it 
shouldn't be considered "fixed".

-Shade


More information about the general mailing list