[OpenID] Verisign Announces Free OpenID Digital Lockbox

Martin Atkins mart at degeneration.co.uk
Sat Feb 21 22:01:38 UTC 2009


Andrew Arnott wrote:
> I fear that the "beauty" of the OpenID/OAuth hybrid will end up making all
> SPs become OPs as well, thereby virtually defeating the promise of OpenID's
> single-sign-on.

Agreed.

We need a way to do hybrid when the OP and the SP are not the same 
party, and ideally we need it sooner rather than later.

The OpenID/OAuth hybrid is a nice UX fix in the short term, but it is 
not good if I'm forced to use a single provider for everything from 
authentication to address books to calendars to whatever else we make 
work with OAuth in future.

It also seems to me that the OpenID part of the OpenID/OAuth hybrid is 
actually redundant in many scenarios. For example, if I'm connecting to 
a PortableContacts endpoint using OAuth, the PortableContacts "self" 
endpoint can in theory provide a superset of the information provided by 
the OpenID transaction.




More information about the general mailing list