[OpenID] rfc2817: https vs http

SitG Admin sysadmin at shadowsinthegarden.com
Tue Sep 2 01:01:44 UTC 2008


>typically last on the order of five minutes, an insanely conservative
>figure.
>
>What we need is something like HTTPS, shareable across protocols, with
>caches that last at least hours, maybe days.

You can use a custom session handler (not too difficult - databases 
work for this) to set your own duration. But the issue here isn't 
convenience, it's security. No matter how impeccable the cryptography 
end is, it can't detect when a thief has broken into the user's home 
and is logging into their sessions. Who logs out when they don't need 
to? Or when a temporary network outage prevents someone (let's call 
her Alice) at a public terminal from logging out (because it's the 
remote server that registers this), and that person doesn't know how 
to delete cookies (or doesn't have the permissions on that system to 
do so), but has to leave before the network comes back up, and the 
next person (let's call him Bob) to visit that site will be prepared 
to log into Bob's account, but instead will find that the site 
recognizes their computer and says "Hello, Alice. Welcome . . . "

-Shade



More information about the general mailing list