[OpenID] [Fwd: Re: guid openid delegate]

[Johnny Bufu]

On 13-Sep-07, at 1:21 PM, Jack wrote:
> What is surprising that a suppliedId such as http:// 
> user.example.com/ is
> not to be subjected to discovery,

How did you arrive at this conclusion?

> whereas user.example.com/ must be
> discovered, in addition to being normalized (and both URLs must be
> subjected to normalisation, yeah? Just because you're a proper URL
> doesn't mean you're normalised).
>
> So absent a clear description of the rationale behind the various
> decisions that have been made, one would assume that a suppliedId that
> is an incomplete URL, once completed, should then be treated in the  
> same
> way as a suppliedID that is a complete URL.

What exactly are you referring to with complete / incomplete URL, and  
the act of completing a URL?


Johnny