[Openid-specs-ab] Spec call notes 26-Jan-12
ejay at mgi1.com
Fri Jan 27 01:07:58 UTC 2012
Spec call notes 26-Jan-12
- Open Issues
Need to formalize interop with a spreadsheet with list of participants
contact information, endpoints, and features tested.
Pam will help setup.
Edmund will provide list of currently known implementations to Mike.
John made suggestions to UMA group to join interop.
Nat may suggest others (NII) to join also.
#521 - Messages 220.127.116.11, etc. - Questioning the ID Token model
Need a FAQ for OpenID Connect to explain rational for the ID Token
John blogged about it at
John will write a shorter version for the FAQ
#522 - All specs - Questioning the complexity of the Connect design
Nat has blogged about this at
The design allows simples things to be simple while also allowing
more complex cases.
Complexity and the number of specs are due to layered architectural
Other specs can be leveraged by others.
#523 - Messages 2.1.4 - session_selection_required is leaking PII
George has updated the issue with a possible solution. He will post
to the list for feedback.
The error codes session_selection_required, consent_required,
user_mismatched will be deleted and
will be replaced with interaction_required
#524 - Messages 2.5.2 - Aggregated and Distributed Claims should be an
Issue is invalid because aggregated and distributed claims are part
of the core feature and was required by others.
OpenID Connect has already been criticized for having too many
#525 - Standard and Messages- Spec organization unnecessarily complex
Marked as invalid because XMPP and other protocol bindings are in
It was proposed in IETF 82 Taipei OAuth meeting that the OAuth spec
be separated into an abstract and protocol binding
as part of rechartering discussions.
#526 - Basic - Basic spec will become the de-facto Connect standard unless
Marked as invalid. If Basic becomes the defacto RP standard, then it
will facilitate adoption.
#527 - Registration - Spec is premature
Marked as invalid. The spec is required for openness and will
promote feedback on what is required.
#528 - Session - Need for spec not apparent
Deferred while spec is being revised.
#529 - Registration 2.3 Error messages should be Bearer
John will fix.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
More information about the Openid-specs-ab